A lawsuit brought by Amazon against Perplexity AI is a foundational battle over the control and regulation of the next generation of AI-powered consumer interactions.
The artificial intelligence revolution is accelerating, and with it, a new frontier of legal and ethical battles is emerging. For those of us in the marketing world, understanding these shifts is about anticipating the future of consumer behavior, brand interaction and digital strategy. The recent lawsuit between tech giant Amazon and AI startup Perplexity AI offers a fascinating glimpse into this evolving landscape, particularly concerning the rise of AI agents.
What Exactly is Perplexity AI?
Firstly, let’s get acquainted with Perplexity.
Perplexity AI is a prominent artificial intelligence startup that has carved out a niche in the AI space, often described as an “answer engine” rather than a traditional search engine. Unlike Google, which provides a list of links, Perplexity aims to provide direct, concise answers to user queries, often citing its sources. It leverages large language models (LLMs) to synthesise information and present it in an easily digestible format.
Beyond its core answer engine, Perplexity has been pushing boundaries with innovations like its browser, Comet, which includes an integrated AI agent. This agent is designed to act as an autonomous digital assistant, capable of performing tasks on behalf of the user – and this is where the current dispute with Amazon ignites.
Amazon Versus Perplexity
Amazon has accused Perplexity AI of covertly accessing customer accounts and disguising AI activity as human browsing through a shopping feature in Perplexity’s Comet browser. Specifically, Amazon does not want Comet’s AI agent to automate placing orders for its users on the Amazon platform.
Why is this a big deal? This clash highlights several critical emerging debates.
Security Risks
Amazon’s concern about “rogue buyers” and unacceptable security risks is paramount. If an AI agent can access and act within a customer’s account, it opens up a Pandora’s Box of potential vulnerabilities, from unauthorised purchases to data breaches. Microsoft’s research simulations, showing AI agents are “quite susceptible to manipulation while shopping,” underscore these fears.
Whose Interest Does the Agent Serve?
This lawsuit forces a fundamental question. When a semi-autonomous AI agent acts on your behalf, whose interests does it truly represent? Is it solely the customer’s, or does the agent’s maker (Perplexity, in this case) also have an agenda (e.g., steering purchases, collecting data)? This impacts consumer trust and liability.
Bullying or Fair Play?
Critics might ask if Amazon is merely leveraging its market dominance to suppress an insurgent competitor. However, the unique nature of AI agent interaction with a proprietary platform adds layers of complexity beyond traditional competitive practices.
The outcome of this lawsuit could set a crucial precedent for how AI agents are allowed to interact with websites and perform tasks across the internet.
Perplexity Underdog?
It’s important to note that Perplexity AI isn’t a universally beloved underdog. The startup, which has attracted significant investment (raising $1.5 billion at a $20 billion valuation), has faced its own share of controversy.
Multiple reputable publications, including Forbes and Wired, have accused Perplexity of directly plagiarising their work, using convincing documentation to demonstrate the unauthorised scraping of content and circumventing explicit prohibitions against it. The Verge has also compiled a comprehensive list of the company’s controversies regarding content acquisition.
This history suggests a company aggressively pursuing market share and profitability, potentially running “roughshod over any competitor it can, tiny or titanic.” Ironically, this ruthlessness might be why Amazon founder Jeff Bezos has reportedly invested in Perplexity twice – perhaps recognising a kindred spirit from his own early days of Amazon’s growth.
What This Means for Marketers?
This lawsuit signals that AI agents automating shopping and other online tasks are not a distant future, but a present reality. Marketers need to consider how their brand presence, product listings and conversion funnels will interact with these autonomous agents, not just human users.
SEO for Agents
If agents are browsing and making decisions, how do we optimise our content and product data for them? This goes beyond keywords to structured data, clear product specifications and easily digestible information.
The Ethics of AI Interaction
Brands must prepare for a future where the lines between user, agent and platform are blurred. Ethical considerations around data privacy, agent transparency and potential manipulation will become paramount. Marketers need to advocate for responsible AI development and deployment.
Content Licensing and Value
The accusations against Perplexity regarding content scraping highlight a critical debate around intellectual property in the AI age. For content marketers, this underscores the need to define the value of their original content. They also need to understand how it might be used (or misused) by AI systems.
The Amazon vs. Perplexity lawsuit is a bellwether for the impending AI agent war. It will redefine how we interact with the internet. In addition how commerce is conducted and how brands need to adapt their strategies to thrive in an increasingly autonomous digital world.
Visit me on LinkedIn.
Read more of my blogs.
About Me
If you enjoy my blogs, you might be curious about my background. I’ve worked in PR and Marketing since 1993. Later, in 1999, I founded a full-service agency and spent the next 24 years successfully growing it. During that time, I had the privilege of partnering with some of the biggest blue-chip brands in the UK and learned extensively from the exceptional marketing professionals I met along the way. Then, in 2023, the management team I built successfully acquired my agency, 8848, setting me free to pursue new passions.
Now, my love of marketing and communications powers our own family venture: a retreat of holiday cottages in the Peak District. I love making brands look and work better, and consequently, in just a few short years, we’ve driven significant growth. In fact, thanks to my focus on SEO, we consistently rank on page one for most key regional search terms, making 2025 our busiest year yet.
Do you need help making your brand or business perform better? If so, I’d love to meet you. I’m based in Ashbourne, Derbyshire but work with companies across the UK and globally.